Loosely packed and firmly packed brown sugar, illustrated

When a recipe calls for brown sugar, the measurement is often qualified with descriptions like “loosely packed”, “lightly packed” or “firmly packed” brown sugar. What does that mean?

Loosely packed means you fill the measuring cup with sugar then use a spatula to remove the mound.

Lightly packed means you press the sugar lightly into the measuring cup and add more, press lightly down again, until the amount of sugar reaches the brim.

Firmly packed means you press the sugar more firmly, packing it in the measuring cup more tightly, adding more and repeating the process until you have a very compact amount of sugar.

To test whether your sugar has been loosely, lightly or firmly packed, fill a measuring cup with sugar then invert the measuring cup onto a plate or bowl. If the sugar does not retain the shape of the measuring cup, it is loosely packed. If the sugar partially retains the shape of the measuring cup (i.e., some come loose), it is lightly packed. If the sugar comes out as a solid mass (i.e., very little comes loose), it is firmly packed.

Does any of it matter? Yes, because the amount of sugar will vary and, ergo, the sweetness, color and texture of the baked product is affected. So, it does pay to use the correct measurement.

  • http://baonkobento.wordpress.com Patricia

    Very useful!

    I’m actually very tamad, and just use “loosely packed” whenever I see brown sugar in recipes. :) Maybe this is why some of my pastries don’t come out as expected. :P

  • Connie

    It does make a difference especially with cookies as the right amount of sugar affects the chewy texture.

  • Natz SM

    I totally agree with Ms. Connie.

    I remember in one of my baking classes that when a recipe calls for brown sugar, it is understood that the sugar should be firmly packed and able to retain its shape UNLESS otherwise stated.

  • Pingback: Chocolate chip peanut butter brownies

  • http://none Crisma

    Yes, that’s correct, Connie. I learned this early on when I was still learning to bake. Besides the correct measurement, the color of the sugar (dark or very dark brown sugar) will spell a big difference in how the cookie texture will turn out. The darker it is, the more moist it will be.

  • Connie

    Oh, thanks for mentioning the color of sugar — another huge factor in baking. :)

  • Mitch

    Will it still make a difference if I use weight measurements instead of volume? thank yoU! :)

  • http://casaveneracion.com/ Connie Veneracion

    Try and find out. :)